A Place to Write

My sister is a wonderful writer and is wanting to turn her dull downstairs basement corner into an oasis of writing inspiration.  She can tell a story like not other, but lacks certain elements and principles of design skills.  To help her with a vision, I put together two quick inspiration boards that I think would help guide in her selection of furnishings, finishes and accessories.     

Option 1: rustic, bright and cheerful.

Option 2: vintage, elegant and refined. 

Any thoughts on which one you like best?